What Chinese vice-president told old friend from US about Communist Party’s legitimacy



In late January, quickly after Joe Biden entered the White Home, Chinese language Vice-President Wang Qishan had a protracted dialog with an American visitor in Beijing.

John Thornton, a Wall Avenue veteran who had beforehand headed Goldman Sachs, is an previous buddy who had identified Wang, President Xi Jinping’s right-hand man, when he was nonetheless a mid-level official within the 1990s.

The pair steered their dialog far past day-to-day politics and talked about Chinese language and American historical past, the conflict of civilisations and one of the vital delicate subjects surrounding the two nations’ relations: the legitimacy of the ruling Chinese language Communist Celebration.

Do you have got questions concerning the largest subjects and traits from all over the world? Get the solutions with SCMP Data, our new platform of curated content material with explainers, FAQs, analyses and infographics dropped at you by our award-winning staff.

Thornton, now the manager chairman of Barrick Gold, relayed the message of the brand new US administration’s priorities: combating the pandemic, reviving the financial system and reuniting a divided America. He stated the non-public ties between Xi and Biden may assist restore relations, and that there was house for the 2 nations to sit down down and talk about commerce.

Thornton additionally had a dialog with China’s high commerce negotiator, Vice-Premier Liu He, and high diplomat Yang Jiechi in the course of the journey, which paved the best way for Liu’s first video name with Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen and US Commerce Consultant Katherine Tai, in June.

“Thornton is an previous buddy of some Chinese language leaders and senior officers,” stated an individual aware of the main points of the dialogue. “As somebody who understands China, he has helped convey messages between the 2 nations when the connection has confronted challenges.

“Thornton has a job much like that of [Henry] Kissinger some 50 years in the past,” stated the particular person, who requested anonymity to debate the matter.

When Kissinger made his 1971 journey to China that culminated within the normalisation of ties between the 2 nations, he was then-president Richard Nixon’s nationwide safety adviser.

Thornton has not had any official authorities position, however he has labored with each Republican and Democratic administrations to function a backchannel – extra in order ties have plunged to their lowest level in a long time.

Officers from the Donald Trump administration outlined the US-China relationship when it comes to a “conflict of civilisations”, and promoted a rhetorical separation of the Chinese language state and its folks from the ruling Communist Celebration – seen by officers in Beijing as extremely provocative and an affront to its political legitimacy.

Wang was keenly conscious of the course by which the Trump administration was pushing, and in the course of the dialog with Thornton he accused the Trump administration of engineering a decoupling between the 2 nations and driving a wedge between the occasion and the folks.

“Wang shared with Thornton observations from the books he examine regime legitimacy,” stated the particular person aware of the dialogue.

In keeping with Wang, the occasion’s legitimacy stemmed from its victory over the Kuomintang within the lengthy civil conflict, China’s course as a socialist nation, 40 years of reform and opening-up insurance policies, and the brand new period below Xi.


China has lengthy been criticised for not having democratic elections, however Wang argued that the occasion was “chosen” by the folks and that they’d given their backing to the regime.

“To grasp China and its historical past, current and future, America must first perceive the Communist Celebration of China,” Wang advised Thornton.

Wang additionally provided his view on American historical past. He stated he noticed US politics, ideology and tradition as stemming primarily from its Anglo-Saxon and Protestant heritage, and tracing again to Mediterranean civilisation – all creating enormous variations with Chinese language civilisation.

He indicated that he hoped the Biden administration would change the US’ course, and that it ought to search to know China no matter whether or not the 2 nations had been pals or enemies – not proceed decoupling.

“The ball is now within the US’ courtroom” concerning relations, Wang stated.

Thornton stated Biden’s local weather envoy John Kerry, who served as secretary of state below Barack Obama, could be a sensible choice for bringing the 2 nations collectively via local weather cooperation.

The dialog between Wang and Thornton provided a uncommon glimpse into the considering of the Chinese language management, particularly on how they noticed the trajectory of China-US relations as Beijing ready to take care of a brand new US authorities.

The Biden administration has since continued a lot of Trump’s robust strategy to China. Biden officers have complained a few lack of communication and entry to Xi’s inside circle.

Officers in Beijing have a mistrust of youthful American officers, whom they contemplate hostile to China and targeted an excessive amount of on ideological competitors. They like to take care of trusted “previous pals” comparable to Thornton, who’s amongst only a few to have maintained ties and entry to a few of China’s strongest officers.

Thornton’s connections to China return to at the very least the mid-1990s, when he first met Wang, then the top of China Development Financial institution.

When Thornton oversaw Goldman’s Asia companies, the Wall Avenue financial institution received the preliminary public providing contract for China Telecom, one of many first worldwide listings by a Chinese language state-owned firm. He left Goldman Sachs in 2003 and have become a professor and director of the worldwide management programme at Tsinghua College in Beijing.

This text initially appeared within the South China Morning Publish (SCMP), essentially the most authoritative voice reporting on China and Asia for greater than a century. For extra SCMP tales, please discover the SCMP app or go to the SCMP’s Fb and Twitter pages. Copyright © 2021 South China Morning Publish Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.

Copyright (c) 2021. South China Morning Publish Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.


Supply hyperlink