Made-Up Sounds Convey Meaning across Cultures


Some gestures could be understood virtually anyplace: pointing to direct somebody’s consideration, for example. New analysis exhibits that sure vocalizations can be iconic and recognizable to individuals all over the world—even when a speaker will not be merely imitating a widely known sound. These findings, revealed in Scientific Studies, could assist clarify the rise of recent spoken language.

In 2015 language researchers challenged some English audio system to make up sounds representing varied fundamental ideas (“sleep,” “youngster,” “meat,” “rock,” and extra). When different English audio system listened to those sounds and tried matching them to ideas, they had been largely profitable. However “we wished to have the ability to present that these vocalizations are comprehensible throughout cultures,” says examine co-author and College of Birmingham cognitive scientist Marcus Perlman.


Credit score: Amanda Montañez; Supply: “Novel Vocalizations Are Understood throughout Cultures,” by Aleksandra Cwiek et al., in Scientific Studies, Vol. 11; Could 12, 2021

So Perlman and his colleagues performed on-line and in-person experiments in seven international locations, from Morocco to Brazil. They recruited greater than 900 contributors, who spoke a complete of 28 languages, to hearken to the best-understood vocalizations from the 2015 investigation and choose matching ideas from a set of phrases or photos. Vocalizations that evoked well-known sounds—for instance, dripping water—carried out greatest. However many others had been additionally understood at charges considerably above likelihood throughout all languages examined, the workforce discovered. “There’s a notable diploma of success exterior of simply onomatopoeia,” Perlman says.

That is seemingly as a result of sure acoustic patterns are common, the workforce suggests. For instance, brief and fundamental sounds typically convey the idea of “one,” and repeated sounds are usually related to “many.” Likewise, low-pitched sounds accompany one thing huge, and high-pitched sounds convey small measurement. These findings of “iconic” sounds may assist scientists perceive how human ancestors began utilizing wealthy acoustic communication, says co-author Aleksandra Ćwiek, a linguist on the Leibniz-Middle Common Linguistics in Berlin. The human voice, she says, would possibly “afford sufficient iconicity to get language off the bottom.”

College of Tübingen linguist Matthias City, who was not concerned within the analysis, agrees. “It’s unclear how phrases got here into being within the first place,” he says. Iconic vocalizations are “doubtlessly one pathway that would have been concerned.”



Supply hyperlink