What Else Has Hong Kong Lost, Readers Ask as a Paper Is Forced to Shut



HONG KONG — Readers lined up within the rain to purchase copies of the Apple Day by day’s ultimate version. They rushed to archive its articles on-line earlier than its web site went clean. Different native information retailers plastered their dwelling pages with studies of the publication’s demise, at the same time as editors puzzled the place the brand new boundaries lay.

Hours after Apple Day by day, one in every of Hong Kong’s most generally learn and impartial information retailers, was pressured to close amid mounting authorities strain, many within the metropolis have been scrambling to protect what elements of its legacy they might. The paper printed its ultimate version on Thursday after a raid on its newsroom, the arrest of prime editors and the freezing of its financial institution accounts made it the largest casualty but in an aggressive marketing campaign by Beijing in opposition to Hong Kong’s as soon as freewheeling information media.

Because the paper put its final version to mattress, a whole bunch of supporters gathered exterior its headquarters within the rain, waving cellphone lights and chanting “Assist Apple Day by day until the tip!”

From a balcony, the newspaper’s staff shone their very own lights, shouting: “Thanks to your help!” Somebody contained in the newsroom taped a defiant message to the window that mentioned in daring print: “You’ll be able to’t kill us all.”

The newspaper mentioned it printed a million copies of Thursday’s version, about 10 instances its common every day circulation, however even that didn’t appear sufficient to satisfy demand, and plenty of shops have been bought out. To many, the rambunctious, usually sensational, proudly pro-democracy publication now stood for greater than only a newspaper: It was a logo of the civil liberties which have been misplaced as Beijing has tightened its grip over town.

“I’m ready for the recollections,” mentioned Jimmy Chan, who runs a liquor retailer within the Kennedy City neighborhood of Hong Kong, as he stood in a line that rapidly fashioned at a newsstand that had simply acquired extra copies of the paper. “It’s for the recollections of the liberty we used to need to say issues in Hong Kong.”

On Twitter and Lihkg, a social media platform standard with town’s activists, readers organized efforts to protect digital data of the newspaper’s protection. Some arrange spreadsheets to establish articles that they’d again up on the Wayback Machine, an internet archive. Others took screenshots of tales that held particular that means for them. Lecturers tried to retain copies for analysis.

“This can be a newspaper with 26 years of historical past. That’s a number of recollections, a number of historical past about Hong Kong,” mentioned Fu King-wa, an affiliate professor on the College of Hong Kong’s journalism college. He downloaded movies of the antigovernment protests that had rocked Hong Kong in 2019 from the information web site’s Fb web page for analysis. However he was solely capable of save a part of what he meant to maintain earlier than they disappeared.

Apple Day by day’s ultimate print situation learn like a colourful time machine, interspersed with farewell messages to its readers. “Hong Kongers Bid a Pained Farewell within the Rain,” learn the highest headline on the paper’s entrance web page. Archival photographs of Hong Kong’s mass protests crammed its pages, in addition to samples of award-winning protection of human rights points.

The paper additionally reported on the courtroom listening to of Tong Ying-kit, the primary particular person to be tried underneath the nationwide safety legislation, which occurred on Wednesday. Hours earlier than Apple Day by day’s web site went darkish, it carried a brand new investigative report on Hong Kong firms that had continued investing in Myanmar after the coup in February.

Now, the newspaper’s social media websites are clean and its dwelling web page directs to a brand new web site, goodbye.appledaily.com, telling subscribers that on-line content material will now not be accessible. “Thanks for supporting Apple Day by day,” it says.

The paper’s closure was prominently lined by information media of varied stripes. Stand Information, a pro-democracy on-line information outlet, confirmed almost 5 hours of stay footage from inside and outdoors the Apple Day by day newsroom on its final night time. On Thursday morning, it posted a 14-minute video

that adopted three editors and a photographer within the final two days earlier than the paper closed. The journalists recounted the challenges of protecting the arrests and courtroom hearings of their colleagues.

The South China Morning Publish, Hong Kong’s largest English-language newspaper, supplied a blended evaluation of Apple Day by day’s legacy. “To its followers, it was a defender of freedoms,” it mentioned. “To its foes, it was the defiler of nationwide sovereignty.”

The authorities have accused the newspaper’s founder, Jimmy Lai, and its prime executives, of protection that posed a risk to nationwide safety, whereas denying that the investigation would hurt press freedom within the metropolis. However Wen Wei Po, a Chinese language government-controlled newspaper, was extra specific about Beijing’s intentions, celebrating Apple Day by day’s demise and calling it a warning to the remainder of the media.

“It’s good for Hong Kong that Apple Day by day got here to a useless finish, and it’s the starting of the purification of the Hong Kong media ecology,” the newspaper mentioned in an editorial.

“The lesson of Apple Day by day’s self-inflicted demise is profound,” it added. “All media in Hong Kong want to consider their very own duty, mission, ethics and backside line.”

Within the metropolis’s newsrooms, journalists frightened if different publications could be focused subsequent. A handful of smaller on-line retailers similar to Stand Information, Hong Kong Citizen Information and Hong Kong Free Press have given voice to town’s beleaguered pro-democracy motion and pursued investigations exposing the federal government’s failures.

Some assumed that each one information retailers within the metropolis, irrespective of how assertive or meek, have been prone to being censured underneath the nationwide safety legislation due to its sweeping scope. The legislation grants Beijing broad powers to crack down on a wide range of vaguely outlined political crimes similar to separatism and subversion. On Wednesday, the police additionally arrested on a columnist at Apple Day by day as a part of the investigation into the paper.

“You already know there’s a crimson line, however on the identical time you don’t know what that line truly is,” mentioned Daisy Li, the chief editor of Citizen Information. Ms. Li had labored for Apple Day by day for 18 years earlier than beginning Citizen Information with different veteran journalists in 2017.

She pointed to the current remarks by a pro-Beijing politician, Stanley Ng, who criticized HK01 and Cable TV, two mainstream information retailers, as being antigovernment. The legislation’s energy and attain lay in its ambiguities, she famous.

“So we do what we did previously. We’re doing journalistic work,” she mentioned. “The consequence of that work could trigger the federal government unhappiness, however that’s journalistic work.”

Apple Day by day’s pressured closure was more likely to deepen a chill that had already set over elements of town’s media. The paper’s overtly antigovernment slant and confrontational posture had supplied a buffer of types for information retailers that have been much less aggressive, mentioned Ivan Choy, a political-science professor on the Chinese language College of Hong Kong.

“Some media occupying a central place will now develop into essentially the most outspoken ones,” he mentioned. “They’ll fear and need to do some self censorship to not comply with the destiny of Apple Day by day.”

Even because the prospects for media freedom within the metropolis appeared daunting, some reporters mentioned they needed to persevere.

“It’s bleak however both you surrender, or do what you possibly can,” Choy Yuk-ling, a distinguished investigative journalist who was lately convicted of constructing false statements to acquire public data for a information report that was vital of the police. “Free speech doesn’t fall from the sky. We used to take it without any consideration however what we will do now could be struggle for that area underneath the constraints.”


Supply hyperlink