A conservative talk radio host once backed the Arizona GOP election recount. Now he’s warning Republicans against it



Mike Broomhead talks for a dwelling, however for a second final week, all he may do was sigh.

With that flash of wordless exasperation behind him, he continued together with his work: delivering the most recent replace on the Maricopa County election recount to listeners of his eponymous morning speak radio present. That day’s information was of a forthcoming conspiracy-theory-riddled documentary on what organizers name an audit — however Broomhead quickly turned his consideration to the officers overseeing this unfolding spectacle.

“You’re turning this into the clown present that you just’ve been accused of. … You’re turning this into the sideshow on the state honest,” he mentioned.

That is the kind of criticism one may anticipate from Democrats, who opposed the recount effort from the start, or from one of many many election consultants who raised alarms on the stark departure from established audit practices, or from a By no means-Trump Republican attempting to wrest the get together from the previous president’s grip.

However Broomhead is a two-time Trump voter, a staunch conservative and a onetime supporter of this recount. In latest weeks, he has customary himself as a actuality test for fellow Republicans.

Because the recount of two.1 million ballots solid seven months in the past drags on, Broomhead and others are considering simply how this saga will finish. The recount’s most ardent supporters imagine former President Trump will probably be reinstated within the White Home (regardless of there being no authorized mechanism for that to happen). Its fiercest critics predict a harmful precedent that can embolden others to baselessly problem outcomes of elections they don’t like.

An more and more vocal share of Arizona Republicans see the recount as an act of self-sabotage, creating an albatross for statewide candidates within the run-up to a pivotal election yr. Broomhead is on this camp, with one other lingering concern.

“Irrespective of the place you stand, the one factor we will all agree on is it has put an ideal massive wedge on this group,” he informed listeners earlier within the week. “That to me is the worst a part of this. It’s another reason for us to face on reverse sides of the streets and complain about one another.”


Seated at his microphone, carrying a Harley-Davidson T-shirt, Broomhead, 54, put in his earbuds, mounted his gaze straight forward and gesticulated as he talked. The unnatural pantomime translated as pure dialog on-air, as he took his listeners on one other recount riff.

“Right here’s the place we stand. It’s June,” he mentioned. “It’s June. We now have lower than a yr and a half earlier than one other election.”

Proponents of the recount, nonetheless, are protecting their eyes firmly mounted on the final election.

Joe Biden gained the state with a wafer-thin margin, a end result instantly contested by Trump and his allies, though they by no means introduced proof of ineligible or altered votes. The Board of Supervisors in Maricopa County, comprising largely Republicans, commissioned two unbiased audits to quell fears of fraud. Each stories mentioned the vote depend was correct.

However Republicans within the state Senate demanded a broader recount and employed an obscure agency, Cyber Ninjas, which didn’t have expertise with audits of this scale and whose chief had promoted baseless theories of rigged voting machines robbing Trump of votes.

Because the recount started at Phoenix’s growing old Veterans Memorial Coliseum, it has been beset with snafus, together with poll safety lapses, opaque procedures and technical errors.

Then there are the conspiracy theories — the seek for nonexistent watermarks or bamboo fibers within the ballots, sparked by unfounded rumors of ballots flown in from Asia. Organizers granted preferential media entry to far-right community OAN, whose personalities are main grass-roots fundraising drives for the recount that don’t disclose donors.

The extra the hassle veered away from expert-sanctioned finest practices and towards groundless hypothesis, the much less Broomhead had religion in its integrity. He tried to think about if the events had been reversed, if liberal Democrats had been pushing an an identical course of. It’s solely honest to confess, he mentioned in an interview, that “Republicans would lose their minds.”

Senate GOP President Karen Fann has mentioned the recount shouldn’t be meant to overturn the 2020 election outcomes however to easily put to relaxation any query in regards to the outcomes and maybe discover methods to enhance elections. (Broomhead mentioned his preliminary assist for the recount was equally to revive voters’ religion within the system, and that he by no means believed the election was stolen from Trump.)

“Whether or not they’re reputable issues or not, our voters — our constituents — should have solutions,” Fann informed The Instances in February. Her spokesman didn’t reply to an interview request final week.

Invoice Gates, a Republican Maricopa County supervisor, mentioned the shambolic nature of the proceedings has completely undermined that purported purpose.

“I don’t see how anybody of their proper thoughts can argue what’s been happening on the coliseum is instilling any voter confidence,” he mentioned.

The evaluate has no authority to alter the 2020 outcomes — and Trump, who often praises the recount, would have come up wanting the presidency even when he had gained Arizona’s 11 electoral votes. Nonetheless, at the least some supporters, and the previous president himself, see the recount as a step in restoring Trump to energy, in line with reporting within the New York Instances and Washington Put up.

Kelly Johnson, a retired lawyer from Huntington Seashore, doesn’t simply hope that’s the case; he’s sure it will likely be. Arizona can be t he “first domino to fall” in overturning the 2020 outcomes, he mentioned, echoing a prediction promoted by believers of QAnon, an amorphous pro-Trump conspiracy concept.


“I’m not 2024” for Trump to win again the White Home, Johnson mentioned. “I’m 2021. I believe one thing will occur by the tip of this yr.”

A man in a Trump shirt with a gun on his hip waves a "Don't Tread On Me" flag

Kelly Johnson has traveled a number of instances from his residence in Huntington Seashore to Phoenix in assist of the GOP-ordered Maricopa County election recount.

(Melanie Mason / Los Angeles Instances)

Johnson, 60, has pushed 3 times to Phoenix to point out assist. In triple-digit warmth, he arrayed his assortment of Trump flags on extendable flagpoles, whereas different supporters relaxed in tenting chairs underneath a cover, surrounded by handmade pro-recount indicators.

Johnson intends to come back again midsummer, when the ultimate report is anticipated to be launched, he mentioned, taking a break from the solar within the taco store throughout the road.

“I believe a whole lot of us type of know what the end result’s gonna be,” he mentioned, however acknowledged he would imagine the Senate Republicans if they are saying no fraud was discovered.

Among the many recount’s harshest critics, few assume that conclusion is probably going.

“There isn’t any state of affairs I can anticipate the place Cyber Ninja’s audit report says, ‘There isn’t any fraud in Arizona,’” mentioned Arizona Secretary of State Katie Hobbs, a Democrat. “The way in which they’ve set it up is primed for cooking the books.”


Broomhead shouldn’t be shy about his opinions — that’s the entire level of being a chat radio host. However anytime he begins to speak in regards to the recount’s backers, his tread turns into notably lighter.

“I don’t wish to make the those who imagine this offended,” he defined throughout a industrial break. “I don’t assume they’re loopy. I believe that these are those who genuinely imagine the election was stolen.”

Each time he talks about these concerned, be it officers like Fann or Ken Bennett, a former GOP secretary of state who has largely been the recount’s public face, or the volunteer poll inspectors on the coliseum, he takes pains to reward their intentions. Nonetheless, he catches warmth from some listeners who accuse him of being biased towards the hassle.

Bitter GOP infighting is hardly new within the state; get together activists continuously clashed with the late Republican Sen. John McCain for not being sufficiently conservative. To Broomhead, this rift is resurfacing on the worst time, proper earlier than the 2022 election, when Arizonans will vote in six statewide races, together with for governor and U.S. senator.

“That division is coming to a head proper now,” he informed his viewers, warning that the state get together’s all-in assist for the audit is leaving average Republicans and independents out of the fold. “And for those who don’t get all people on board … we’re going to watch the Democrats win nearly all of these six necessary races.”

For state legislators in protected GOP districts, backing the recount is nice politics. A ballot by HigherGround, an Arizona consulting agency, discovered that greater than three-quarters of Republicans assist the audit. Profitable over that base of voters ensures a main victory, and successfully, reelection.

However the identical ballot discovered that 55% of Arizonans general oppose the hassle, which suggests it may drag down statewide and swing district candidates come November 2022.

The recount has already rippled into subsequent yr’s governor’s race, which Hobbs jumped into final week. Days earlier, OH Predictive Insights, a Phoenix-based pollster, had put Hobbs on the high of its energy rankings of Arizona officers, based mostly partially on her rising identify recognition and favorability. Mike Noble, the agency’s director of analysis, tied her surge to her high-profile problem to Cyber Ninjas and the state Senate.

“The GOP retains offering their chin to Hobbs in a proverbial political sense, and he or she retains capitalizing every time they stick their chin out, which appears very often within the audit,” Noble mentioned.

Most Republican hopefuls for statewide workplace have largely stayed mum on the subject, frightened of alienating both their get together’s base or the broader citizens. Additionally quiet is termed-out GOP Gov. Doug Ducey, whilst Trump continues to blast him for certifying the election final fall.

“The very fact this isn’t being referred to as out by different Republican elected officers is mind-numbing to me,” mentioned Gates, the Maricopa County supervisor.

Because the recount drags on, some Arizona Republicans are shedding endurance. The Maricopa County Board, which had lengthy opposed the recount, has ratcheted up its pushback with unusual vehemence. Former GOP Gov. Jan Brewer mentioned auditors ought to “name it quits,” talking in an interview on “The Gaydos and Chad Present,” Broomhead’s afternoon counterparts on KTAR 92.three FM. Two GOP state senators have signaled various levels of discomfort with the proceedings.

Within the best-case state of affairs, mentioned Rebecca Rios, the state Senate Democratic chief, these legislators would “come to their senses and work with Democrats to close the audit down.”

All indications, although, are that this drama is about to dominate Arizona’s political panorama for a while. There are stories the state Senate is contemplating yet one more digital recount. The Maricopa County Board is primed to sue the state Senate, whereas American Oversight, a nonpartisan anticorruption nonprofit, has gone to courtroom searching for public information relating to the recount.

And the query of the overall price ticket stays unknown, significantly after Hobbs informed the county it ought to acquire new voting machines as a result of these turned over to the state Senate might have been compromised.

That is what Broomhead fears — months extra of preposterous headlines. It might make for nice radio, nevertheless it won’t be nice for his get together, or his state. And so he retains speaking in regards to the recount, bemoaning the debacle it has grow to be and hoping its officers will hear.


Supply hyperlink