Microsoft’s Bing Briefly Blocked ‘Tank Man’ on Tiananmen Anniversary



Microsoft’s Bing search engine briefly blocked pictures and movies of the well-known “tank man” of Tiananmen Sq. on Friday, the anniversary of China’s bloodbath of pro-democracy protesters in 1989, in what the corporate mentioned was an error.

Customers exterior China reported that the search engine had returned textual content outcomes for “tank man” — as the unknown particular person, carrying buying luggage, who blocked a line of tanks in central Beijing after the killings has turn out to be recognized. However Bing’s video and picture tabs displayed no references to the occasion.

It was unclear how geographically widespread the filtering was.

The “tank man” pictures are routinely blocked inside China, as are different references to the army’s crackdown on the Tiananmen Sq. protesters, which left tons of or extra useless.

Microsoft didn’t instantly reply to a request for remark. A Microsoft spokeswoman mentioned in a press release that the filtering was as a result of “unintended human error” and that the corporate was working to resolve the issue. By early Saturday, the location was as soon as once more returning the video and picture outcomes.

Microsoft is the one main international firm that runs a censored search engine inside China. It has struggled to appease the nation’s regulators, who closely censor the web and fear concerning the safety of know-how made by American firms. For its half, the US authorities has more and more punished Chinese language firms that it says are tied to on-line repression and surveillance.

China’s web censorship often will get even tighter across the anniversary of the Tiananmen killings. The authorities block the whole lot from footage of candles and tanks to indirect references invented by web customers to get across the controls, like utilizing “Could 35” to imply June 4.

Sometimes, that censorship spills over the Chinese language borders. Final 12 months, the video-chat app Zoom disrupted a number of digital commemorations of the Tiananmen crackdown that activists hosted. The corporate finally restored the activists’ accounts and mentioned that its blocks mustn’t have affected individuals exterior China.


Microsoft started providing a filtered model of Bing for China in 2009. Throughout the nation’s borders, a search on Bing for the Dalai Lama, for instance, turns up Chinese language state-media accounts that accuse the non secular chief of stirring up hatred and separatism. Exterior China, it brings up websites like Wikipedia.

In 2019, Bing briefly disappeared from the Chinese language web, elevating fears that one of many nation’s few alternate options, nonetheless imperfect, to the Chinese language search engine Baidu had disappeared.

Microsoft has tailor-made different merchandise to satisfy China’s calls for. It has labored with China Electronics Expertise Group, a state-run electronics maker with shut ties to the army, to supply a model of its Home windows software program that the Chinese language authorities considers safe. This previous week, President Biden barred People from investing in that firm and 59 others in China, on the grounds that they’re concerned with surveillance know-how that the authorities use to repress dissent and spiritual minorities.

Microsoft’s skilled social community, LinkedIn, runs a separate, filtered model of the location inside China. In March, China’s web regulator rebuked the corporate’s executives for not censoring delicate political content material earlier than a key assembly of Chinese language lawmakers.

One other tech firm, the Israeli net design agency Wix, was criticized this previous week for flattening a web site run by pro-democracy activists in Hong Kong on orders from the police within the metropolis, the place China has been stifling dissent. In a press release, the corporate apologized and mentioned taking the location down had been a mistake.


Supply hyperlink